Troubled Bridge Over Water

In the recent blog post A pain in the… I described my summer holiday fun being a cycling tour round the Baltic coast.

You meet a lot of data quality issues on such a tour.

One experience was when we arrived in the Polish town Świnoujście. I planned the tour using Google Maps. According to the plan we would arrive in Świnoujście from the west, cross the bridge over the river Świna and reach the ferry to Sweden on the east bank close to the railway station.

Nice plan. Only thing: Opposite to what’s shown on Google Maps – and told in the route planner, there is no bridge across the river in the real world.

Fortunately there was a free ferry service across the river. So we did catch the once a day big ferry to Sweden in time.

PS: The road name on the bridge on Google Maps is by the way Wodna. Wodna is Polish for (something with) water.

Bookmark and Share

9 thoughts on “Troubled Bridge Over Water

  1. Richard Ordowich 17th July 2011 / 15:05

    Is the bridge shown on paper maps? Do GPS’s show the bridge?

    Is this another conspiracy on the part of Google to change the world by removing links between countries, changing borders and perhaps planting objects in their satellite views that do not really exist? Or does Google Maps represent a parallel universe? Be afraid, be very afraid. Google is slowly taking over our minds.

    • Henrik Liliendahl Sørensen 18th July 2011 / 07:30

      Right Richard. I should have crosschecked with Wikipedia. The article about Świnoujście shows a map without a bridge and says that a tunnel will be finished in 2013.

  2. Prashanta C 18th July 2011 / 15:42

    Very interesting blog Henrik, Loved it.

    Good news is, Google has been updating their maps and route information over the years. For example, if you were to search the driving distance between Stanford to Stockholm few years back, Google would say – Swim across the Atlantic Ocean (That’s 3,462Mi, How on earth a human being do that?). [Link here – http://googlesystem.blogspot.com/2007/03/google-maps-shows-funny-directions.html%5D

    I guess, most of us would prefer Google acknowledging that they don’t know some of the things instead of making the maps look stupid. It will help both Google and millions of people who rely on these maps.

    • Henrik Liliendahl Sørensen 18th July 2011 / 16:18

      Prashanta, thanks for joining. I’m sure Google is improving both the route planning algorithms and the reference data behind the maps and services all the time.

      What we sometimes see is a common circumstance with global reference data, which is that they reflect the different national reference data and sometimes makes mistakes in standardization. One explanation for the not existing bridge (or tunnel) could be a false translation of a ferry service.

  3. Daryl Swinden 19th July 2011 / 10:27

    Hi Henrik,
    My understanding is that many map providers put a few false entries in their mapping (like seeds in a database) to understand who is copying their content. Perhaps you have just been unlucky in discovering one of these?

    • Henrik Liliendahl Sørensen 19th July 2011 / 11:51

      Thanks Daryl, such seeds are really damaging when using external reference data for real world alignment.

  4. Dan Power 19th July 2011 / 22:42

    Great article, Henrik – gave me a good chuckle – keep up the good writing!

    • Henrik Liliendahl Sørensen 20th July 2011 / 03:52

      Thanks Dan.

  5. Saumya Chaki 20th August 2013 / 13:03

    Hi Henrik,

    Nice post..i have a take on data quality issues in maps..often it is man made due to differences in opinion between countries over disputed areas..no serious attempt is really made to resolve these issues..regarding quality of Google maps..in my view the accuracy varies from country to country..for instance in India i find quite a few errors at street level..this is partly due to poor quality digitized maps in the country..so part of the blame lies with the government agencies that create these maps..often errors are not corrected for years..Google does use local maps as a source which causes the quality issues to persist..

    Regards,
    Saumya

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s